17 May, 2016
I mentioned this recipe in my Eggs Benedict recipe although I have also used it with steak. I learned to make this sauce from WeAreNotMartha. I am borrowing their recipe with my modifications and directions.
The trick to this sauce is to constantly be whisking and watching the temperature. You absolutely need a double boiler to make this work. Doesn’t have to be a fancy double boiler but direct heat won’t work.
- 3 egg yolks Hand separated works fine
- 1 T Water
- 1 T Lemon Juice Fresh squeezed is best, but bottled works
- 1.5 sticks butter
- pinch Salt
- pinch white pepper Black works but changes the look of the sauce
Separate egg yolks place in a metal bowl or top of double boiler
Add lemon juice and water
Whisk until smooth
Get your double boiler going, once the water is boiling bring the temperature down. If you don't, the eggs will cook which we don't want.
Get your butter soft. Microware works but you want something that is just think enough to maintain structure and be cut into pieces but soft enough you can stir it in. I cut mine into about 6-8 pieces per stick.
Place the top half of the double boiler on and start whisking. Get everything on the sides and bottom. Don't let the eggs cook. Take the top off the heat if you see the eggs start to cook. Feel free to move on and off.
You should see the entire volume froth, increase in volume and thicken. When it is solid enough that the whisk lets you see the bottom of the bowl for a second before returning, take off the heat.
Add a chunk or two of butter and continue to whisk. You can add more butter as the complete emulsion forms. You want to keep adding butter until it becomes creamy and smooth and becomes a pale yellow. This is a taste thing and it takes a while to find the right level for you. You might use all of the butter or you might not, but it takes about 1.5 sticks for me to get it where I like it. Don't be afraid to go back to heat if becomes to solid.
Add salt and pepper to taste. Add a little more lemon juice for taste.
You want to keep the sauce warm. Sometimes I have the heat off on the double boiler and will rest it on the still hot water to keep things warm.